Oregon fire chief spares job of firefighter who went on a drunken, racist rant at training conference
Portland's chief shares her thought process in disciplining firefighter
Looking for a quality used fire truck? Selling one? Visit our sponsor Command Fire Apparatus
I urge you to read the detailed statement (below) from Portland (OR) Fire & Rescue Chief Sara Boone outlining her thought process in dealing with an enormously ugly episode involving a Portland firefighter. Chief Boone writes that shortly after she became the first Black woman to lead the department, Firefighter Nick Perkins went on a drunken, racist rant against a Black hotel clerk. It occurred last August in Nashville, Tennessee where Perkins was representing the department at a health training seminar.
It’s not hard to see how termination is a justifiable punishment for this act. Chief Boone took a different direction, outlining a multi-faceted discipline package. The details are from Chief Boone’s statement (scroll down for the entire statement):
The firefighter’s discipline includes the following: a six-month unpaid suspension and a Last Chance Employment Agreement that has built in steps to give this employee the tools he needs to not only confront his own racism, but to actively become anti-racist. Elements of the Last Chance Employment Agreement include a multi-step education process led by Portland’s Office of Equity and Human Rights where this firefighter will be teamed up with a racial equity mentor; a requirement that he donate $5,000 to one of a selected groups of non-profits that focus on racial equity; a course of outside racial equity training; and a requirement that he not drink alcohol.
On the first night of the trip, documents detail that Perkins got too intoxicated and tried entering the hotel in the early morning hours with his credit card instead of his room key.
After his failed attempt to get into the hotel, the clerk working at the time, a Black woman, spoke to him through the front door’s phone. The documents show she asked Perkins for his name and room number and he responded – calling the woman racial slurs.
The documents provided go on to detail what happened next – claiming Perkins continued to beat and kick the hotel door in an attempt to get in and hotel management called the Nashville Metro Police. Perkins was then flown home.
Chief Sara Boone’s statement:
A local news outlet is reporting on a racist incident that occurred in August 2019 connected to Portland Fire & Rescue and I want to speak directly to the public about the incident and my decisions regarding discipline in this case.
Soon after I was sworn in as Portland Fire & Rescue’s first Black fire chief, I was notified about an incident involving one of our firefighters who was at a conference in Nashville, Tennessee. The allegations in the report were appalling and shook me to the core as both a Black woman and chief of a public safety bureau. Reading the initial report, my reaction was anger that this could even occur and a deep sadness for the harm caused to the victim.
What happened: One of our firefighters got drunk and when he found himself locked out of his hotel, he became verbally aggressive with the Black woman working the front desk and used derogatory and offensive racial slurs to intimidate her.
The woman reported the incident to Portland Fire & Rescue the next day. She wanted to inform the bureau about the incident, not to get the firefighter dismissed, but because she wanted us to take action to make sure something like this never happened again.
First, I want to thank this woman for having the courage to come forward and report this incident. I also want to acknowledge the grace in which she made her intentions known. As we moved forward through the investigative and disciplinary process, she remained centered in my heart with each step. I am truly sorry that one of our employees caused her the type of pain that all Black women experience and know on a visceral level, myself included.
As head of the bureau, I had to keep an unbiased perspective during the investigation to keep the process fair. I maintained neutrality and objectivity as I considered all the evidence. In the end, the final determination of discipline was mine and mine alone.
At the conclusion of the investigation, I spoke at length with the firefighter in question. Based on my interview with him, his deep contrition, and how he expressed a true commitment to explore the racism he had never known to be a part of himself, I decided not to terminate him but to continue to extend that grace the victim offered with mercy. I also weighed the damage this incident had on the public trust, especially to the Black community. Ultimately, I created a discipline package based more on a restorative justice model where the road to redemption will require work and commitment from the employee.
The firefighter’s discipline includes the following: a six-month unpaid suspension and a Last Chance Employment Agreement that has built in steps to give this employee the tools he needs to not only confront his own racism, but to actively become anti-racist. Elements of the Last Chance Employment Agreement include a multi-step education process led by Portland’s Office of Equity and Human Rights where this firefighter will be teamed up with a racial equity mentor; a requirement that he donate $5,000 to one of a selected groups of non-profits that focus on racial equity; a course of outside racial equity training; and a requirement that he not drink alcohol.
This firefighter will have to walk a long path to earn the trust of his co-workers and his community, but he will not walk alone. In response to this incident, the union that represents firefighters and PF&R administration signed a binding agreement for leadership of both entities to engage in multi-level bias and antiracism training. As an organization we have much to learn from this incident and as an organization we must change. The woman who suffered so much from this abhorrent act asked for us to make sure that this doesn’t happen again: I keep her request close to me as I lead the work for change.
Statement from IAFF Local 43 president Alan Ferschweiler:
Portland Fire Fighters Association supports the disciplinary action taken by Fire Chief Sara Boone. It is our moral and ethical duty to conduct ourselves in a professional, respectful manner at all times. We apologize for failing to meet those expectations and we must learn from our mistakes. This is an opportunity for all of us to reflect, grow and do better for ourselves and our community.
